Should you turn off HEIC on your iPhone?
What the Most Compatible setting actually changes, the second setting almost nobody finds, and why your photos can still arrive as HEIC after you switch.

Ama Mundum LLC Team5 min read
Nobody wakes up wanting to change an image format setting. The question is almost always standing in for a different one: my photos will not open on the other person's computer, how do I stop that happening.
Turning HEIC off is one answer to that. For most people it is the expensive answer, and it often does not even work, for reasons that are not obvious.
If you have not met the format before, what a HEIC file is covers the ground this piece assumes.
What the switch actually does
The setting is in Settings, then Camera, then Formats, and it offers High Efficiency or Most Compatible. Choosing Most Compatible means the camera writes JPG from that moment on.
Three things it does not do, each of which catches people out:
- It does not convert the photos already on your phone. Everything shot before today stays exactly as it is. If your problem is a photo from last summer, this setting cannot help you at all.
- It does not change what AirDrop sends.
- It does not change what your computer receives over a cable. That is a different setting entirely, and it is the next section.
The setting almost nobody finds
Settings, then Photos, then Transfer to Mac or PC. It has two options, Automatic and Keep Originals, and it governs what leaves the phone when you plug it into a computer.
Keep Originals sends the HEIC exactly as stored. Automatic is supposed to convert to JPG when it judges that the receiving computer cannot read HEIC.
Two honest caveats about Automatic. It is a judgment the phone makes, not a guarantee, and it is widely reported to be unreliable on Windows in particular, where codec and driver changes have moved the goalposts. The result also depends on the application doing the importing, so the same phone and the same cable can behave differently in two programs.
This setting is the single most common reason for "I already turned HEIC off and the files are still HEIC". People change the camera format, which affects new photos, and then transfer old ones, which this setting governs.
Why your photos still arrive as HEIC
| What you are seeing | What is actually happening |
|---|---|
| Old photos are still HEIC | The camera setting only applies to new ones |
| Photos arrive as HEIC over a cable | Transfer to Mac or PC is on Keep Originals, or Automatic guessed wrong |
| Some apps send JPG, others send HEIC | Each app decides for itself whether to convert when you share |
| Files from iCloud are HEIC | Downloading the original gives you the original |
That third row is worth sitting with, because it is the one that makes the whole thing feel random. Sharing a photo is not one mechanism, it is a different piece of software each time, and each one chooses whether to hand over the file as stored or re-encode it on the way out. There is no setting that governs all of them, which is why the behavior is worth testing with the specific app you use rather than assuming.
What switching costs
Storage, roughly doubled. That is the whole reason HEIC exists. Every photo you take from now on takes about twice the space, on the phone and in iCloud, for a picture that looks the same.
Color depth. JPG stores eight bits per channel against HEIC's ten. You are unlikely to see it on a normal photo and quite likely to see it as banding across a clear sky or a gradual sunset.
And the structural problem with the trade: every photo pays, so that the occasional shared one is convenient. You take thousands and send a handful. Switching the format optimizes for the handful at the cost of all the rest.
What I would actually do
Leave it on High Efficiency and convert the few photos that need to travel. This is the right answer for most people: you keep the small, high quality originals, and the inconvenience lands only on the photos that were going somewhere anyway.
Switch to Most Compatible if you hand photos to Windows users or upload them to older systems regularly, and the cost of thinking about it each time is worth more to you than the storage. A photographer sending proofs to clients all day has a real case. Someone who emails a picture to their accountant twice a year does not.
Either way, change Transfer to Mac or PC to match. If you want JPG on your computer, that is the setting that decides it, and it is the one most people never touch.
Worth remembering that none of this is permanent. Both settings flip back in a few seconds, and nothing you have already taken is altered by either of them.
Converting the ones that travel
- HEIC to JPGOpen tool for sending, uploading or printing. Up to thirty photos at once
- HEIC to PNGOpen tool when you need it lossless or with transparency
- Compress imageOpen tool for when the JPG comes out heavier than the HEIC it replaced, which it generally does
These run in your browser and nothing is uploaded, which is the part that matters when the files in question are your own camera roll.


